Here's the reason why I don't keep a personal fish list, nor do I think keeping a group list is worthwhile:
Because nearly everyone I play with is a fish! I used to keep player notes for the bad players, but eventually realized there were so many of them that it was a better idea to mark the GOOD players.
Seriously, I commend you for the idea, but if we were to all list all the fish we ran in to just TODAY, if we each played for just ONE HOUR, the list would be massive and thus useless. No one is going to spend the time it takes to add that many players to a buddy list, when all the need to do is fire up a table with a high average pot or a high FS% (if available) and the'll get action nearly as good.
In addition, a lot of people (myself excluded) seem to hate playing with bad players who make bad calls for some reason, so they would have no interest in this list either.
And lastly, if we limited this to the really, really, really bad players (say, 90% VPIP and up and those who call with 9 high and lower), while that may be a useful list, we all know those guy won't be around in a week anyway, so the list would quickly outdate itself.
As I said though, I applaud the idea. I just don't think the reward is worth the effort. If other disagree, by all means, post away! If nothing else, it will be an entertaining read.
P.S.
stormswa
Limit: Any
Site: Any
